Pizza restaurants

Sophia's Pizzeria

4.2 219 reviews Closed 110 Old York Rd Suite 204, New Cumberland, PA 17070, United States

Discover this place

Sophia's Pizzeria, nestled in New Cumberland, PA, has quickly become a favorite for those seeking authentic Italian flavors. The establishment showcases a rich menu, featuring a variety of delightful pizzas like the Margherita and Old World Pizza, as well as hearty paninis such as the Caprese and Chicken Parmesan. Customers rave about their dining experiences, with reviews highlighting the remarkable quality of the food and the welcoming atmosphere. Deb praises the authentic Italian roots and exceptional service, emphasizing the family's commitment to customer satisfaction. Nathan Keel notes the abundance of ingredients in the Sophia's Special Sub and the delightful garlic knots, which were substantial enough to be a meal on their own. The new location enhances the dine-in experience, as Codie Culley reflects on the inviting ambiance and the phenomenal pinwheels. Meanwhile, Steph Tichenor applauds the Detroit pizza, pairing it with an Italian sub packed with fresh meats and cheeses, demonstrating the pizzeria's commitment to quality and taste. Overall, Sophia's Pizzeria stands out not just for its delicious offerings, but for the warmth and hospitality that accompanies every meal, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Sophia's Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Sophia's Pizzeria

4.2

219 reviews

100%

11%

22%

Review highlights

Based on 219 reviews

Reviews of Sophia's Pizzeria consistently highlight its authentic Italian cuisine and generous portions, particularly praising the quality of the dough, sauces, and fresh ingredients. Customers frequently commend the variety of menu options, including subs, specialty pizzas, and unique items like pinwheels and garlic knots. The friendly and accommodating staff receive notable recognition for their willingness to go above and beyond to enhance the dining experience. The recent relocation to a new, inviting space has also been well-received, improving both dine-in comfort and delivery convenience. Overall, Sophia's Pizzeria is seen as offering great value, excellent food, and a welcoming atmosphere that encourages repeat visits.

Deb

Jun 02, 2025

Love these guys!! Authentic Italian cuisine from a authentic Italian family. So glad they just moved to their current location! As long as I've known them they will basically go above and beyond for ANYONE!! If you need something ?? ASK !! Need to stand in out of the cold ? ASK !!!! Need to charge your phone a quick minute? ASK!!! In all the time I've been alive in this great thing we call earth ...it's a show of respect....to just ask first ! ( I am not a owner or employee) Just a loyal customer!

Nathan Keel

Jun 01, 2025

Really good experience...had the Sophia's Special Sub which was packed with meat and cheese. Also had the garlic knots which would have been a meal by themselves. Great food and good value for the money. Ordered online, paid online and they brought it out to the car once I arrived. I will return!

Christopher Jacobs

May 16, 2025

First time having food from this restaurant and it did not disappoint. The first pizza was huge and was one of the best pizzas I have ever experienced. The dough was perfect and the sauce was excellent. We also tried four of their fries. Messy but worth it!

Codie Culley

May 13, 2025

The new location is awesome for dine in ! I stopped to try the new pinwheels they offer and they are nothing short of amazing ! If you haven’t tried their food or met their friendly staff then you’re missing out!

Steph Tichenor

May 04, 2025

Went for the Detroit pizza and it was the best! The Italian sub was served on homemade roll and filled with lots of fresh meats and cheeses. Delicious. Staff was friendly and restaurant was inviting. Will definitely go back.

Sadiyq Naji aka (King Saji)

Apr 30, 2025

Definitely try their “Spin Wheels” They’re absolutely deliciously different. Yummy

B K

Apr 14, 2025

I saw they had pinwheels on their menu online. So I took a chance and went in to have one. I ordered the Buffalo chicken pinwheel and it was the best one I've ever had! It took me back to 15 years ago when I lived in New York and ate pinwheels at a local pizzeria. Thank you for an amazing meal! I will definitely be back!

dennis k.

Mar 28, 2025

I was traveling from out of State (NJ) and trying decide what I should eat. I was headed for a motel in New Cumberland, PA. I Googled “pizza” in New Cumberland area and Sophia’s popped up. I read a few reviews. Overall rating is 4.2, I believe, which is respectable. However, a read a few negative reviews. Some criticized the pizza, complaining it was burnt. I was pleasantly surprised when I picked up the large pie, based on those negative reviews. The pizza was very good: nice amount of cheese, nice texture crust - not burnt. Young woman who took my order over phone was very pleasant. A few steps away from pizzeria is a liquor/beer/wine store